They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. If that’s the case, Macy Gray’s Talking Book– a full-length cover of one of Stevie Wonder’s most famous albums of the same name- is surely the highest form of praise. In fact, rather than imitating, Macy has aimed to put her own spin on the 70s funk-pop classics. She’s called it a love letter to Stevie on the 40th anniversary of this iconic Motown record.
Macy’s is probably one of the most distinct female voices in the music business since she came on the scene at the turn of the century. ‘Distinct’ meaning you either love her deep, raspy tone… or loathe it. Admittedly, I haven’t really gotten into many of her tunes since I became obsessed with “I try” in ’99 and of course her appearance on The Black Eyed Peas “Hey DJ” (back when they weren’t making generic pop, dance, are-you-actually-serious music).
If you aren’t too familiar with Stevie’s work apart from the fact that he’s blind and wears dark glasses, then you’ll at least know “Superstition”. I’ve always imagined as a musician the most popular songs would be the most difficult to reinterpret. Macy has managed to create a slow, moody jazz version of this 1972 hit on her album-length retake. At first listen, it’s easy to dismiss as a little dull in comparison to the upbeat, oh-so-familiar Wonder version. That said, it grows on you. Again said, nothing can compare to that original, though many have tried.
With quite beautiful versions of “You are the sunshine of my life”, “Big Brother” and ballad “Blame it on the sun”; Talking Book is sure to please the true Macy fans and quite possibly delight Wonder lovers too. There’s no denying her unique pop, soul voice is perfect for this female interpretation of an iconic male funk icon.
Sometimes, Talking Book doesn’t quite hit the right notes though. Her version of “Maybe Baby” feels a bit harsh and uncomfortable. In this case, the man knows his catchy funk, while the woman knows her slow blues best.
All up, a pretty good go at something unbeatable. Call it a tribute as you will.
6.8 out of 10
